Roman v. Volkswagen of America, L-07-1106 (5-2-2008)

**Roman v. Volkswagen of America: Court Rules Against Employee in Warranty Dispute** This case involved a dispute over a vehicle warranty claim. The employee, Roman, sued Volkswagen of America and a car dealership (Ed Schmidt Pontiac-GMC) claiming they breached their warranty obligations when her car's engine failed. Roman argued that she had properly maintained her vehicle according to the warranty requirements, and therefore the companies should cover the repair costs. The appellate court ruled in favor of Volkswagen and the dealership. Even though Roman had expert testimony stating her engine was well-maintained, the court found she couldn't provide enough documentation proving she had followed the required oil maintenance schedule. Without sufficient paperwork to back up her warranty claim, the court granted summary judgment against her, meaning she lost the case without it going to trial. **What this means for workers:** This case highlights the critical importance of keeping detailed maintenance records when you have warranty coverage on company vehicles or equipment. Courts require solid documentation, not just expert opinions, to prove warranty compliance. Always save receipts, service records, and follow manufacturer guidelines precisely to protect yourself in warranty disputes.