Barbara Lundell v. Lois Hubbs

Excerpt

In this negligence action arising from the plaintiff's injuries sustained while attempting to traverse the aisle of a moving school bus, the trial court granted the defendants' motion for summary judgment following a determination that (1) the plaintiff had not demonstrated that the defendants had breached any duty of care to the plaintiff and (2) alternatively, any reasonable fact-finder could only conclude that the plaintiff was at least fifty percent (50%) at fault for her injuries. In so finding, the trial court declined to consider the plaintiff's captioned "Declaration" in part because it failed to meet the affidavit requirements of Tennessee Rule of Civil Procedure 56.06. In filing her "Declaration" in support of her opposition to summary judgment, the plaintiff sought to amend her prior deposition testimony concerning the location of her fall. The trial court additionally denied the plaintiff's "Motion to Deem Requests for Admission Admitted" after the plaintiff averred that the defendants had failed to respond to the plaintiff's initial requests for admission for over five-hundred days. The plaintiff has appealed. Having determined that genuine issues of material fact exist regarding the defendants' breach of duty of care and comparative fault, we reverse the trial court's granting of summary judgment in favor of the defendants and the trial court's finding that the plaintiff's "Declaration" should not be considered. We affirm the trial court's denial of the plaintiff's "Motion to Deem Requests for Admissions Admitted."