Skip to main content
Claim Type

Workers’ Compensation Cases

227 employment law court rulings from public federal records (2000–2026)

227
Total Rulings
33%
Plaintiff Win Rate

69 of 206 adjudicated opinions ended in a plaintiff win.

DC
Top Court

About Workers’ Compensation Claims

Workers' compensation claims arise in the context of employment law when employers retaliate against employees for filing workers' compensation claims or when disputes arise about coverage and benefits. Most states prohibit termination or other adverse actions against employees who exercise their workers' compensation rights.

Case Outcomes

Defendant Win
123 (54%)
Plaintiff Win
69 (30%)
Remanded
21 (9%)
Mixed Result
13 (6%)
Dismissed
1 (0%)

Related Laws

Court Rulings (227)

Mohammed Bouayad v. Normandy Insurance Company
Fla. SupremeJul 9, 2026Florida
Plaintiff Win
Mtiri, Lotfi v. Encompass Health Rehabilitation Hospital of Memphis
TENNWORKCOMPAPPJun 18, 2026Tennessee
Mixed Result
Dodge
Conn.Apr 21, 2026Connecticut

Pursuant to the Workers' Compensation Act (§ 31-293 (a)), an injured employee may assert a claim against and recover damages from a tortfeasor who is allegedly liable for the employee's work-related injury, even if the employee is entitled to workers' compensation benefits for that injury, and an…

Defendant Win
Joyce Scruggs v. Just Food for Dogs
DELSUPERCTMar 26, 2026Delaware
Defendant Win
Auto Owners Insurance v. Labor Commission
UTAHFeb 26, 2026
Defendant Win$571,523.29 at issue
LJ & J Corporation and Hastings Mutual Insurance Company v. John Henry
IOWACTAPPFeb 25, 2026Iowa
Mixed Result
The Uninsured Employers' Fund v. Jose A. Zacarias Perez
VACTAPPFeb 24, 2026
Plaintiff Win
Jonathan Mohler v. Robert A. Young III Dba Cross Creek Ranch, LLC, Employer; Midwest Insurance Company, Carrier
Ark. Ct. App.Feb 18, 2026
Plaintiff Win
Taye
Ohio Ct. App.Jan 8, 2026

Motion for summary judgment; Civ.R. 56; workers' compensation claim; R.C. 4123.01(C)(5); preexisting condition; substantially aggravated; clear and unambiguous statute; and objective pre-injury medical evidence. The trial court erred when it granted an employer's motion for summary judgment because…

Plaintiff Win
Brinks Global Services v. Labor Commission
Utah Ct. App.Dec 26, 2025
Defendant Win
Shaw-Hicks
DELSUPERCTDec 16, 2025
Defendant Win
Schmidt
Ohio Ct. App.Dec 11, 2025

Workers' compensation; spinal stenosis; expert opinions; manifest weight; high-dose steroids. The trial court's judgment finding that plaintiff was entitled to additional workers' compensation benefits was not against the manifest weight of the evidence even though there were conflicting expert…

Plaintiff Win
Zawada
ARIZCTAPPDec 2, 2025
Defendant Win
Erin Lindsay v. Minneapolis Public School District (SSD1), Self-Insured, Relator
Minn.Oct 22, 2025

1. The employee's injury occurred "in the course of" employment for the purpose of Minnesota Statutes section 176.021, subdivision 1 (2024), because the undisputed facts show that the employee sustained the injury within an hour of the end of the workday, the injury occurred at the workplace, and…

Plaintiff Win
The Uninsured Employer's Fund v. Vanessa Hughes
Unknown CourtJul 8, 2025Virginia

Commission did not err awarding temporary total disability and medical benefits for compensable injury by accident arising out of employment; credible evidence supports finding Rose as employer had power to control appellee as employee, rather than independent contractor; injury arose out of…

Defendant Win
State ex rel. Allen Industries, Inc. v. Indus. Comm.
Ohio Ct. App.Dec 23, 2024

Objections to magistrate's decision recommending denial of relator's request for a writ of mandamus ordering the Industrial Commission of Ohio to vacate its order granting an employee's application for an additional award of compensation based on a violation of a specific safety requirement and…

Defendant Win
Brian Coblentz v. Tractor Supply Company
Tenn. Ct. App.Apr 26, 2024

A sales representative for a product vendor was injured while in a Tractor Supply store performing his job. The sales representative received workers' compensation benefits from his employer, a hardware product company, and then proceeded with a tort case against Tractor Supply. We agree with the…

Defendant Win
Willie Rambo v. Kelly Natural Gas Pipelines, LLC and Midwest Employers Casualty Company
MISSCTAPPMar 12, 2024
Defendant Win
C. Adam Toney Discount Tires v. Eric Compton
WVACTAPPJun 15, 2023
Plaintiff Win
Honemond
DCJun 15, 2023
Defendant Win
Asli M. Ali, V. Wa State Department Of Labor & Industries
Wash. Ct. App.Jun 12, 2023
Defendant Win
University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences and Public Employee Claims Division v. Kenneth Barton
Ark. Ct. App.Apr 27, 2022
Plaintiff Win
Hill
DCApr 21, 2022
Defendant Win
Derinda Carr v. Windham Professionals, Inc.
Tenn.Apr 14, 2022

Appellant Derinda Carr challenges the trial court's finding her neck injury did not arise primarily "out of and in the course and scope of' her employment. The appeal has been referred to the Special Workers' Compensation Appeals Panel for a hearing and a report of findings of fact and conclusions…

Defendant Win
District of Columbia Public Schools v. District of Columbia Department of Employee Services
DCOct 28, 2021
Mixed Result$51,544.97 awarded
Stevenson
Utah Ct. App.Sep 30, 2021
Defendant Win
Bethany Shelton v. Hobbs Enterprises, LLC
Tenn.Sep 27, 2021

Bethany Shelton ("Employee") filed a petition for benefit determination against Hobbs Enterprises, LLC ("Employer") alleging an injury to her right shoulder suffered in a work- related accident on August 26, 2017. She sought temporary total, permanent partial, and continued medical benefits.…

Defendant Win
McAlpine
Ohio Ct. App.Jul 16, 2021

Home health aide sought workers' compensation benefits after she fell in the wet grass in the side yard of her client's home and sustained an injury to her back. The employee had completed her shift, had stayed with the client (a long-time friend) for approximately 15 minutes after her shift, and…

Defendant Win
VIRIDIANA REGALADO VS. F&B GARAGE DOOR (2018-24810, DIVISION OF WORKERS COMPENSATION)
NJSUPERCTAPPDIVJun 8, 2021
Defendant Win
WSI
N.D.Jun 3, 2021

Section 65-01-02(11)(a)(3), N.D.C.C., requires claimants to prove a compensable heart-related injury by showing with reasonable medical certainty their employment caused the injury and unusual stress was at least 50% of the cause of the injury. Objective medical evidence may not be established…

Defendant Win
Wright
Utah Ct. App.Apr 15, 2021
Defendant Win
Ackley
Utah Ct. App.Apr 15, 2021
Plaintiff Win
JBS Carriers v. Labor Commission
Utah Ct. App.Apr 15, 2021
Defendant Win
Barr v. Darlington County School District
SCCTAPPApr 7, 2021

Kenneth L. Barr, Employee, appeals the decision of the Appellate Panel of the Workers' Compensation Commission denying his claim for medical and compensation benefits. Employee asserts injury as a result of exposure to volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in the paints he used while working as a…

Defendant Win
Imelda Magdaleno v. Walmart Stores & Department Of Labor & Industries
Wash. Ct. App.Nov 23, 2020
Defendant Win
David White v. Centurylink Inc. And Department Of Labor And Industries
Wash. Ct. App.Nov 9, 2020
Defendant Win
Browning
Ohio Ct. App.Aug 12, 2020

EVIDENCE — WORKERS' COMPENSATION: Where the defendant-employer asserted on appeal that the trial court had failed to consider all the exhibits before rendering judgment, the court did not err in granting plaintiff-employee the right to participate in the workers' compensation fund for the condition…

Plaintiff Win
Coleman Turner v. Department Of Labor & Industries
Wash. Ct. App.Aug 3, 2020
Defendant Win
Vincent Scerri v. Department Of Labor & Industries
Wash. Ct. App.Jun 30, 2020
Defendant Win
FRETT
Ga.Jun 16, 2020
Plaintiff Win
Massengale
Utah Ct. App.Mar 26, 2020
Defendant Win
Wasatch Electric v. Labor Commission
Utah Ct. App.Feb 13, 2020
Plaintiff Win
Nielsen
Utah Ct. App.Jan 3, 2020
Defendant Win
Smith, Zackery Steven v. Everidge, Inc.
TENNWORKCOMPCLNov 27, 2019Tennessee
Mixed Result
Lane, Michael L. v. Viskase Companies, Inc.
TENNWORKCOMPCLNov 21, 2019Tennessee
Plaintiff Win
Harris-Williams
Ill. App. Ct.Nov 19, 2019
Defendant Win
Pritchard
Utah Ct. App.Nov 15, 2019
Defendant Win
Transport America v. Illinois Workers Compensation Comm'n
Ill. App. Ct.Nov 4, 2019
Defendant Win
Straughn
DCAug 29, 2019
Defendant Win
State ex rel. Stallion Oilfield Constr., L.L.C. v. Indus. Comm.
Ohio Ct. App.Aug 8, 2019

We deny relator's request for a writ of mandamus compelling the Industrial Commission to vacate its order granting respondent's request for TTD. Respondent did not voluntarily abandon his employment by violating a written policy Relator did not follow its own policies regarding drug testing.

Defendant Win

Showing 1–50 of 227 rulings · Page 1 of 5

Think you may have a workers’ compensation claim?

Check which employment laws may protect you — free, private, and no sign-up required.

Data sourced from public federal court records via CourtListener.com. Case outcomes extracted using AI analysis. This information is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. The classification of claim types is based on automated analysis and may not reflect the full scope of each case.