Skip to main content
Claim Type

Constructive Discharge Cases

572 employment law court rulings from public federal records (18792026)

572
Total Rulings
20%
Plaintiff Win Rate
$378,054
Avg Damages (24 cases)
E.D.N.Y.
Top Court

About Constructive Discharge Claims

Constructive discharge occurs when an employer makes working conditions so intolerable that a reasonable person would feel compelled to resign. The employee must show that the employer deliberately created or knowingly permitted conditions that were so difficult that resignation was a foreseeable consequence. These claims are often paired with underlying discrimination or harassment allegations.

Case Outcomes

Defendant Win
233 (41%)
Mixed Result
145 (25%)
Plaintiff Win
113 (20%)
Dismissed
46 (8%)
Remanded
32 (6%)
Settlement
3 (1%)

Top Employers in Constructive Discharge Cases

Employers most frequently appearing in constructive discharge rulings.

Court Rulings (572)

Copes
D. Md.Jan 2, 2025Maryland
Dismissed
Lamar Myers v. Chantel D Contreras
C.D. Cal.Jan 2, 2025California
Mixed Result
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission v. Mariscos El Puerto, Inc.
D. Nev.Dec 31, 2024Nevada
Mixed Result
Trippett
S.D.N.Y.Dec 16, 2024New York
Mixed Result
United States Equal Employment Opportunity Commission v. Chipotle Services, LLC
D. Kan.Dec 3, 2024Kansas
Plaintiff Win
ATLAS DATA PRIVACY CORPORATION v. NUWBER, INC.
D.N.J.Nov 26, 2024New Jersey
Mixed Result
Jessica Tuffley v. Employment Security Department
Wash. Ct. App.Nov 20, 2024
Defendant Win
Insulet Corporation v. EOFlow, Co. Ltd.
D. Mass.Oct 31, 2024Massachusetts
Mixed Result
Cohen
S.D.N.Y.Oct 24, 2024Massachusetts
Defendant Win
Newton
N.D. OhioOct 22, 2024Ohio
Mixed Result
AFSHAR
D.N.J.Oct 11, 2024New Jersey
Dismissed
Edison
E.D. Mich.Oct 2, 2024Michigan
Defendant Win
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission v. Mariscos El Puerto, Inc.
D. Nev.Oct 1, 2024Nevada
Mixed Result
HUTCHERSON
W.D. Pa.Sep 30, 2024Pennsylvania
Dismissed
Williams v. The City of New York
E.D.N.Y.Aug 22, 2024New York
Defendant Win
Guerrier
E.D.N.Y.Aug 16, 2024New York
Dismissed
Prophete
E.D.N.Y.Aug 5, 2024New York
Dismissed
Montgomery v. ExchangeBase, L.L.C.
Unknown CourtJul 3, 2024

Summary judgment Civ.R. 56 expanding allegations on summary judgment disparate treatment sex discrimination hostile work environment constructive discharge appellant's burden on appeal App.R. 12(A)(2) App.R. 16(A)(7). It was appellant's burden, as the appellant, to affirmatively demonstrate reversible error in the record and to substantiate her arguments in support thereof. Appellant did not show that the trial court erred in granting summary judgment in favor of appellees on appellant's claims of sex discrimination, hostile work environment, constructive discharge, violation of public policy, or intentional infliction of emotional distress. Appellant made no mention of her claims for violation of public policy or intentional infliction of emotional distress in her appellate brief. As to her remaining claims, while appellees met their burden under Civ.R. 56(C), presenting evidence of specific facts in the record demonstrating their entitlement to summary judgment based on the lack of evidence of essential elements of each of appellant's claims, appellant did not meet her reciprocal burden of demonstrating the existence of a genuine issue of material fact for trial on her claims. Appellant did not apply the applicable legal standards and did not show, based on evidence in the record, that a reasonable factfinder could find in favor of appellant on her sex discrimination, hostile work environment, or constructive discharge claims. Review of the record did not reveal any genuine issues of material fact that would preclude summary judgment in favor of appellees.

Mixed Result
Fernandez
S.D.N.Y.Jul 1, 2024New York
Defendant Win
Hendershot
W.D. Ky.Jun 28, 2024Kentucky
Dismissed
Prince
D. Md.Jun 28, 2024Kentucky
Defendant Win
CAVANAGH
D. Me.May 28, 2024Maine
Mixed Result
Hoglund
Cal. Ct. App.May 17, 2024
Plaintiff Win$2,447,430 awarded
Callahan
N.D. Ill.May 10, 2024Illinois
Defendant Win
Sandra Ziots v. Promedica Employment Services LLC
Mich. Ct. App.Apr 25, 2024
Defendant Win
Iglhaut
E.D.N.Y.Apr 15, 2024Idaho
Mixed Result
Boyd
N.D. Ill.Mar 29, 2024Illinois
Mixed Result
Lawrence
M.D. Tenn.Mar 27, 2024Tennessee
Defendant Win
ATLANTIC SPINE CENTER, L.L.C. v. DELOITTE, LLP GROUP INSURANCE PLAN
D.N.J.Mar 12, 2024New Jersey
Mixed Result
Hoffstead
N.D. Ill.Feb 27, 2024Illinois
Defendant Win
Twerdahl
Unknown CourtJan 30, 2024

The plaintiff sought to recover damages from the defendant school district for her alleged constructive discharge from employment as a teacher. The plaintiff had been employed by the defendant for approximately twenty-four years when she resigned from her position in August, 2019. On December 19, 2019, she filed an age discrimination complaint with the Commission on Human Rights and Opportunities (CHRO). There- after, the CHRO issued a release of jurisdiction over the complaint, and the plaintiff commenced the present action against the defendant, alleging a violation of the Connecticut Fair Employment Practices Act (§ 46a-51 et seq.), constructive discharge, and breach of contract. The plaintiff, who was seventy years old, claimed that she was forced to resign after the defendant created an intolerable work environment by marginalizing and unfairly criticizing her because it wanted to replace her with a younger teacher. The defendant filed a motion to strike the plaintiff's complaint on the grounds that it was untimely and failed to state a claim on which relief could be granted. The trial court granted the defendant's motion, and, thereafter, the plaintiff filed an amended complaint alleging only constructive discharge. In that complaint, the plaintiff added allegations related to a report issued by the defendant on June 10, 2019, in which it acknowledged that an assistant principal had copied certain portions of the plaintiff's prior evaluations into her 2016–2017 school year evaluation and recommended a review of adminis- trators' practices of referencing evaluations from prior years. The defen- dant filed a motion to strike, which the trial court granted, finding that the plaintiff's complaint to the CHRO was untimely pursuant to the 180 day limitation period set forth in the applicable statute ((Rev. to 2019) § 46a-82 (f)), because the plaintiff had failed to identify conduct relating to an intolerable working environment that had persisted to June 22, 2019, o

Dismissed
Hill
N.D. OhioJan 24, 2024Puerto Rico
Defendant Win
Schnuerle
D. IdahoJan 16, 2024Idaho
Defendant Win
Clifton Walker v. Charles Edward Banks
C.D. Cal.Jan 9, 2024California
Mixed Result
Canales Bonilla v. Stefano Ristorante, Inc.
M.D. Fla.Dec 18, 2023Florida
Plaintiff Win
Natalie C. Grimsley v. Patterson Company, LLC
Unknown CourtNov 7, 2023

The Plaintiff brought suit against her former employer, alleging sexual harassment by her supervisor and claiming constructive discharge. The Employer moved to compel arbitration based on a provision in the Plaintiff's employment agreement. The Plaintiff responded by invoking the federal Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act of 2021, which the trial court concluded invalidates the mandatory arbitration provision. We reverse the trial court's decision because the harassment of the Plaintiff and her constructive discharge occurred prior to the effective date of the Act.

Defendant Win
Lewis
D. Md.Nov 3, 2023Maryland
Defendant Win
Christopher Frankovich v. Home Depot U.S.A., Inc.
C.D. Cal.Oct 11, 2023Illinois
Plaintiff Win$28,956.5 awarded
Carr
N.D. Ill.Oct 4, 2023Illinois
Defendant Win
Ricchio
N.D. Ill.Sep 18, 2023Illinois
Mixed Result
Dutton
D. IdahoSep 13, 2023Idaho
Defendant Win
U.S. EQUAL EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY COMMISSION v. COASTAL DRILLING EAST, LLC
W.D. Pa.Jul 28, 2023Pennsylvania
Plaintiff Win$24,375 awarded
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission v. Golden Entertainment, Inc.
D. Md.Jun 22, 2023Maryland
Mixed Result
Madrid
D. IdahoJun 15, 2023Idaho
Defendant Win
Tijerina
S.D. Cal.Jun 14, 2023California
Mixed Result
Marcelo
W.D. Wash.Jun 9, 2023Washington
Defendant Win
McDonough
D. Colo.May 4, 2023California
Plaintiff Win
Estrada
D. Colo.May 3, 2023California
Plaintiff Win
Ikema
S.D. Cal.Apr 10, 2023California
Dismissed
Dowling
E.D. Mo.Mar 27, 2023Missouri
Defendant Win

Showing 51100 of 572 rulings · Page 2 of 12

Think you may have a constructive discharge claim?

Check which employment laws may protect you — free, private, and no sign-up required.

Data sourced from public federal court records via CourtListener.com. Case outcomes extracted using AI analysis. This information is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. The classification of claim types is based on automated analysis and may not reflect the full scope of each case.