Skip to main content
Claim Type

Workers’ Compensation Cases

227 employment law court rulings from public federal records (2000–2026)

227
Total Rulings
33%
Plaintiff Win Rate

69 of 206 adjudicated opinions ended in a plaintiff win.

DC
Top Court

About Workers’ Compensation Claims

Workers' compensation claims arise in the context of employment law when employers retaliate against employees for filing workers' compensation claims or when disputes arise about coverage and benefits. Most states prohibit termination or other adverse actions against employees who exercise their workers' compensation rights.

Case Outcomes

Defendant Win
123 (54%)
Plaintiff Win
69 (30%)
Remanded
21 (9%)
Mixed Result
13 (6%)
Dismissed
1 (0%)

Related Laws

Court Rulings (227)

State ex rel. Cugini v. Timken Co.
Ohio Ct. App.Jul 25, 2019

Under State ex rel. Klein v. Precision Excavating & Grading, Co., 155 Ohio St.3d 78, 2018-Ohio-3890 and on the record of the case, the magistrate correctly reasoned that relator failed to demonstrate the Industrial Commission abused its discretion in denying his request for temporary total…

Defendant Win
Stewart
Ohio Ct. App.May 13, 2019

Bureau of Workers' Compensation appeals trial court's decision finding injured worker entitled to participate in compensation fund. Worker was company president. Company provided mobile commercial tire changing services. President injured while traveling to breakfast meeting with company employee,…

Defendant Win
Joann McCrary v. Georgia Employee Retirement System
Ga. Ct. App.Mar 21, 2019
Defendant Win
State ex rel. Calhoun v. Indus. Comm.
Ohio Ct. App.Feb 28, 2019

Mandamus denied relator's refusal to subject himself to an examination by his employer's physician does not constitute good cause under R.C. 4123.65(C).

Defendant Win
Vallier
WISCTAPPFeb 26, 2019
Defendant Win
State ex rel. Klein v. Precision Excavating & Grading Co. (Slip Opinion)
OhioSep 27, 2018

Workers' compensation—When a claimant voluntarily removes himself from his former position of employment for reasons unrelated to a workplace injury, the claimant is no longer eligible for temporary-total-disability compensation, even if the claimant remains disabled at the time of his separation…

Defendant Win
Steen, Nicole v. IDEXX Laboratories, Inc.
TENNWORKCOMPCLSep 7, 2018
Defendant Win
Garner
Ohio Ct. App.Aug 24, 2018

The trial court did not err by entering summary judgment for Appellees on Appellant's claim for workers' compensation benefits for injuries sustained in an assault. Appellant did not receive his injuries "in the course of" his employment, and the injuries did not "arise out of" his employment.…

Defendant Win
Bennett
Ohio Ct. App.Jul 30, 2018

Trial court's determination that claimant did not meet his burden to establish that he had asbestosis for workers' compensation claim affirmed.

Defendant Win
Harley-Davidson Motor Co. Grp., LLC v. Labor & Indus. Review Comm'n
WISCTAPPJul 24, 2018
Defendant Win
Green
Ohio Ct. App.Jun 26, 2018

Workers compensation: trial court's findings of fact and conclusions of law were sufficient for appellate court to conduct review trial court did not err in admitting testimony competent and credible evidence supports judgment of the trial court.

Defendant Win
Draper
Ohio Ct. App.Jun 1, 2018

Trial court's grant of summary judgment in favor of appellant's employer and the Administrator of the Bureau of Workers' Compensation on the basis of res judicata was improper where one of appellant's prior workers' compensation claims was vacated prior to adjudication and a question of fact exists…

Remanded
State ex rel. Nationwide Children's Hosp. v. Indus. Comm.
Ohio Ct. App.May 8, 2018Ohio

Case in mandamus where self-insured employer is attempting to overturn the granting of permanent total disability compensation since the evidence before the Industral Commission fully supported the commission's order, the request for a writ is denied.

Defendant Win
David Hous. v. U.S. Dep't of Labor
W.D. Ky.Mar 26, 2018Kentucky
Defendant Win
Catherine Lyons v. Chittenden Central Supervisory Union
VTMar 16, 2018
Plaintiff Win
Ellis
Ohio Ct. App.Mar 13, 2018

Trial court erred by granting directed verdict in favor of employer on claim for lumbar radiculitis. Although testimony from claimant's medical expert was equivocal on whether lumbar radiculitis was a pain symptom of another condition or an independent condition, it was not proper to weigh the…

Mixed Result
Battle
DCJan 4, 2018
Plaintiff Win
Osten
Ohio Ct. App.Dec 29, 2017Ohio

The trial court did not err in concluding that Appellant, a traveling employee, was on a personal errand at the time of her injury and was not entitled to receive workers' compensation benefits. Affirmed.

Defendant Win
Waite
UTAHDec 1, 2017
Defendant Win
Petersen
UTAHDec 1, 2017
Defendant Win
Adamczyk, Adam v. Prospect, Inc.
TENNWORKCOMPCLNov 20, 2017
Plaintiff Win
Rojas
Utah Ct. App.Nov 16, 2017
Defendant Win
Cox
Utah Ct. App.Sep 14, 2017
Plaintiff Win
Ball
N.C. Ct. App.Aug 15, 2017

Workers' Compensation N.C. Gen. Stat. Sec. 97-2(5) Fair and just results Method 3

Plaintiff Win
BEVERLY GOULD VS. CORIZON HEALTH OF NJ(NEW JERSEY DEPARTMENT OF LABOR, DIVISION OFWORKERS' COMPENSATION)
NJSUPERCTAPPDIVAug 7, 2017
Plaintiff Win
Oliver
UTAHJul 25, 2017
Defendant Win
Gadalean
Or. Ct. App.Jun 14, 2017
Plaintiff Win
Clendenin
OhioMay 18, 2017

Workers' compensation-Appeal-R.C. 4123.512-Decision that preexisting condition substantially aggravated by workplace injury has returned to preinjury level is a decision regarding the extent of a claimant's disability and is not appealable-Court of appeals' judgment reversed.

Defendant Win
Magadan, Victor v. JS Gardening LLC
TENNWORKCOMPCLMay 16, 2017
Plaintiff Win
Commonwealth of Kentucky, Uninsured Employers' Fund v. Morgan Crayne
KYApr 18, 2017
Plaintiff Win
Valdez
Utah Ct. App.Apr 6, 2017
Defendant Win
JP's Landscaping v. Labor Commission
Utah Ct. App.Mar 30, 2017
Plaintiff Win
State ex rel. Mike Coates Constr. Inc. v. Indus. Comm.
Ohio Ct. App.Feb 28, 2017

It was within the fact-finding discretion of the Industrial Commission to reject relator-employer's affidavits and suggested inference, and to determine, on the facts of the case, that the perpetration of a fraud in receiving TTD compensation did not necessarily mean that the initial injury did not…

Defendant Win
Franklin
Ohio Ct. App.Feb 23, 2017

Workers' compensation coming-and-going rule totality of the circumstances. Trial court erred in awarding employer summary judgment by application of the coming-and-going rule where there were genuine issues of material fact as to whether accident arose out of and in the course of employee's…

Remanded
Molton
Ohio Ct. App.Feb 17, 2017

The trial court did not err by entering summary judgment for Appellee on Appellant's claim for workers' compensation benefits. Generally, the coming-and-going rule bars compensation of a fixed-situs employee for injuries which occur off the work premises. Neither the zone-of-employment exception or…

Defendant Win
Commonwealth of Kentucky, Uninsured Employer's Fund v. Michael Brock
KYFeb 14, 2017
Defendant Win
Miller v. Horizons Health Servs., L.L.C.
Ohio Ct. App.Feb 9, 2017

Summary judgment Civ.R. 56 workers' compensation R.C. 4123.01 arising out of employment causal connection idiopathic injury. In order to survive defendants-appellees' motion for summary judgment, plaintiff-appellant had the burden of producing evidence demonstrating that a condition, risk, or…

Defendant Win
Samuel
Ohio Ct. App.Feb 2, 2017

Workers' compensation R.C. 4123.512 de novo scope of review failure to object to absence of exhibits to notice of hearing and deposition transcripts constitutes waiver. A trial court's scope of review on appeal from a workers' compensation determination pursuant to R.C. 4123.512 is, unlike…

Defendant Win
Poremba
NEVJan 26, 2017
Plaintiff Win
Arsenio Mojares v. RK Chevrolet, Inc. and VADA Group Self-Insurance Association
VACTAPPNov 22, 2016
Defendant Win
Adams, David A. v. Lifepoint Hospitals, Inc.
TENNWORKCOMPCLNov 16, 2016
Defendant Win
Petersen
Utah Ct. App.Nov 3, 2016
Defendant Win
LISA COOK, Claimant-Respondent v. MISSOURI HIGHWAY AND TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION, Employer-Appellant.
Mo. Ct. App.Oct 25, 2016Missouri
Plaintiff Win
Crumble, Mae v. Express Employment Services
TENNWORKCOMPAPPOct 12, 2016Tennessee
Remanded
Carrera Ex Rel. Department of Labor & Industries v. Olmstead
Wash. Ct. App.Oct 4, 2016Washington
Remanded
Adams, Larita v. Verizon Wireless
TENNWORKCOMPCLAug 18, 2016
Defendant Win
Hutchings
Utah Ct. App.Jul 29, 2016Utah
Defendant Win
Kovacs
Wash.Jul 14, 2016
Plaintiff Win
M.C. DEAN, INC. v. DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA DEPARTMENT OF EMPLOYMENT SERVICES, & ANTHONY LAWSON, Intervenor
DCJul 7, 2016District of Columbia
Defendant Win
POREMBA VS. SO. NEVADA PAVING
NEVApr 7, 2016
Plaintiff Win

Showing 51–100 of 227 rulings · Page 2 of 5

Think you may have a workers’ compensation claim?

Check which employment laws may protect you — free, private, and no sign-up required.

Data sourced from public federal court records via CourtListener.com. Case outcomes extracted using AI analysis. This information is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. The classification of claim types is based on automated analysis and may not reflect the full scope of each case.