Skip to main content
Claim Type

Failure to Accommodate Cases

3,417 employment law court rulings from public federal records (18942026)

3,417
Total Rulings
14%
Plaintiff Win Rate
$1,166,440
Avg Damages (163 cases)
S.D.N.Y.
Top Court

About Failure to Accommodate Claims

Failure to accommodate claims arise when an employer does not provide reasonable accommodations for an employee with a disability or sincerely held religious belief. Under the ADA and Title VII, employers must engage in an interactive process to identify effective accommodations unless doing so would cause undue hardship. Common accommodations include modified schedules, assistive technology, and workplace modifications.

Case Outcomes

Defendant Win
1351 (40%)
Mixed Result
726 (21%)
Dismissed
497 (15%)
Plaintiff Win
480 (14%)
Remanded
220 (6%)
Settlement
143 (4%)

Court Rulings (3,417)

Mlsna, Mark v. Union Pacific Railroad
W.D. Wis.Jul 12, 2023Wisconsin
Plaintiff Win$2,990,149.96 awarded
Hammonds
M.D. Ala.Jul 11, 2023Alabama
Plaintiff Win
Brister
M.D. Pa.Jul 10, 2023Pennsylvania
Mixed Result
Cipolla
N.D. Cal.Jul 3, 2023California
Mixed Result
True
D. UtahJun 28, 2023Utah
Defendant Win
Cruz-McCoy
S.D. Cal.Jun 28, 2023California
Dismissed
Freeman
W.D. La.Jun 27, 2023Louisiana
Defendant Win
Estrada
E.D. Cal.Jun 26, 2023California
Remanded
Harmon v. Unum Life Insurance Company of America
E.D. Tenn.Jun 23, 2023Tennessee
Defendant Win
Lavelle-Hayden
Or. Ct. App.Jun 22, 2023
Remanded
Lavelle-Hayden
Or. Ct. App.Jun 22, 2023
Remanded
DiMeglio
S.D.N.Y.Jun 22, 2023New York
Settlement
Cordero
S.D.N.Y.Jun 21, 2023New York
Settlement
Childs
Ohio Ct. App.Jun 20, 2023

Judgment affirmed. Although the appellant designated only the trial court's final judgment in his notice of appeal, this court could address the trial court's interlocutory rulings because interlocutory orders merge with a court's final judgment. The trial court did not err by denying the appellant's motion to compel, motion for sanctions, motion to strike, or motion in limine. The appellant failed to demonstrate that his employer either waived its ability to rely on, or was prevented from relying on, his criminal background as the grounds for terminating his at-will employment. The trial court did not err by denying appellant's motion for judicial notice or motion for summary judgment. The trial court properly granted appellees summary judgment on appellant's claims of race discrimination, disability discrimination, retaliation, wrongful termination in violation of public policy, unlawful aiding and abetting of discrimination, and defamation.

Defendant Win
Newell
S.D.N.Y.Jun 20, 2023New York
Defendant Win
Mance
N.D. OhioJun 20, 2023Ohio
Defendant Win
Newell
S.D.N.Y.Jun 20, 2023New York
Dismissed
Gomez
E.D. Wis.Jun 19, 2023Wisconsin
Dismissed
Velazquez
S.D.N.Y.Jun 16, 2023New York
Dismissed
Jones
S.D.N.Y.Jun 16, 2023New York
Settlement
Madrid
D. IdahoJun 15, 2023Idaho
Defendant Win
Phan
S.D. Cal.Jun 14, 2023California
Dismissed
Equal Employment Opportunity Commission v. Telecare Mental Health Services of Washington Inc
W.D. Wash.Jun 12, 2023Washington
Defendant Win
Parada
S.D. Ill.Jun 9, 2023Illinois
Mixed Result
Carabajo
E.D.N.Y.Jun 9, 2023New York
Defendant Win
Marcelo
W.D. Wash.Jun 9, 2023Washington
Defendant Win
Wingra Redi-Mix Inc. v. Labor & Industry Review Commission
WISCTAPPJun 8, 2023
Plaintiff Win
Melody J. Rodgers v. Judge Sun
C.D. Cal.Jun 7, 2023California
Mixed Result
Arthur Gutierrez v. Anning-Johnson Company
C.D. Cal.Jun 6, 2023California
Dismissed
La Riccia v. Ohio Civ. Rights Comm.
Ohio Ct. App.Jun 1, 2023

Ohio Civil Rights Commission discrimination disability R.C. 4112.06 R.C. 4112.05 Americans with Disabilities Act, App.R. 12 App.R. 16 abuse of discretion OCRC record pre-complaint investigation no probable cause finding. Pro se appellant filed a complaint with the Ohio Civil Rights Commission against the Cleveland Clinic Foundation alleging that the hospital discriminated against her based on her disability because the hospital denied her provider of choice after the appellant sent numerous inappropriate messages to her doctor through the hospital's MyChart messaging system. The OCRC made a finding of no probable cause and dismissed her complaint. On appeal to the trial court, the court upheld the commission's decision. On appeal to this court, appellant argued that the OCRC submitted an incomplete record to the trial court, the trial court ignored her evidence, and the OCRC misinterpreted the law. The OCRC did not submit an incomplete record to the trial court and the trial court did not err when it did not consider the pro se appellant's additional filings because they were not part of the commission's record and the trial court determined that it would only consider the commission's record and the parties' briefs. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in determining that the OCRC's finding of no probable cause is not unlawful, irrational, arbitrary or capricious. Appellant did not show that her behavior was caused by her alleged mental disability, but even if she had so shown, the hospital did not terminate the physician-patient relationship because of appellant's alleged disability. The hospital offered to assist appellant to find another provider within the hospital system that could provide more suitable treatment.

Defendant Win
Ray
W.D. Tenn.May 26, 2023Tennessee
Remanded
HONAUER
D.N.J.May 25, 2023New Jersey
Defendant Win
ST. MARIE v. PIKE TELECOM & RENEWABLES, LLC
E.D. Pa.May 24, 2023Pennsylvania
Defendant Win
McGarrity
M.D. Fla.May 23, 2023Florida
Dismissed
Mata
W.D. Wash.May 19, 2023Washington
Defendant Win
KAPLOW
D.N.J.May 12, 2023New Jersey
Remanded
SYDER
D.N.J.May 11, 2023New Jersey
Remanded
Hilbert
S.D.N.Y.May 5, 2023New York
Defendant Win
Santiago
D. Or.May 4, 2023Oregon
Mixed Result
Marquise Bailey v. VSA Asset Management LLC
C.D. Cal.May 3, 2023California
Mixed Result
Goins
N.D. Cal.Apr 20, 2023California
Mixed Result
Morgan
M.D. Pa.Apr 18, 2023Pennsylvania
Defendant Win
Dove
Unknown CourtApr 17, 2023

Objections Civ.R. 53(D) Disability Discrimination Reasonable Accommodation Assault Battery Ratification. After trial, plaintiff filed objections to the magistrate's decision. The court overruled plaintiff's objections on her disability discrimination claims, finding that plaintiff's requests for transfer to two other facilities were not reasonable accommodations. However, the court sustained plaintiff's objection on her assault and battery claims, finding defendant ratified its employee's assault and battery upon plaintiff. Therefore, the court modified the magistrate's decision, rendered judgment in favor of plaintiff on her assault and battery claims, and referred the case to the magistrate for a determination of damages on the assault and battery claims.

Plaintiff Win
Escobedo
E.D. Cal.Apr 12, 2023California
Dismissed
Simon
N.D. Ill.Apr 12, 2023Illinois
Defendant Win
Troulliet
E.D. La.Apr 11, 2023Louisiana
Dismissed
Doherty
N.D. Cal.Apr 5, 2023California
Mixed Result
Lowe
N.D. Ala.Mar 28, 2023Alabama
Dismissed
Dowling
E.D. Mo.Mar 27, 2023Missouri
Defendant Win
Ambrose
M.D. Fla.Mar 27, 2023Florida
Plaintiff Win$45,000 awarded

Think you may have a failure to accommodate claim?

Check which employment laws may protect you — free, private, and no sign-up required.

Data sourced from public federal court records via CourtListener.com. Case outcomes extracted using AI analysis. This information is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. The classification of claim types is based on automated analysis and may not reflect the full scope of each case.